# The Ethical Dilemmas of Teleportation: A Deep Dive
Written on
Chapter 1: Understanding Teleportation
For many years prior to the conflict, I managed a channel on a Russian-speaking platform, which led to numerous engaging discussions. One particularly thought-provoking conversation began with the question: “How does teleportation theoretically function, and can the teleported entity be viewed as a replica rather than the original?”
Teleportation encompasses various theories, ranging from quantum teleportation—where the state of a group of particles is transferred—to the concept of disassembling an object into its particles, transporting them, and then reconstructing the object elsewhere.
To achieve teleportation, it's essential to gather data about the position and state of every particle in a body. This information must then be sent to the destination via classical communication methods, which are limited by light speed. Consequently, a precise copy is constructed from the available particles. Whether we are transferring the state of particles or disassembling and reassembling them, the fundamental challenges remain largely unchanged.
One significant issue is that quantum mechanics forbids obtaining simultaneous data about a particle's location and state (as stated in Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle), making the creation of a flawless copy based on available information unfeasible. While it might be possible to generate an approximate version of the object, the implications of this—especially in the context of teleporting living beings—remain uncertain. Would the teleported entity even be viable? Furthermore, we end up with a replica post-teleportation, not the original, even if it is constructed from the same atomic materials.
This brings forth a series of ethical questions. For instance, if we were to teleport a human—disassembling their body into atoms—could this be viewed as a form of death? The new body would merely be a duplicate that shares a similar consciousness. If we lack a “spiritual” essence that transfers between bodies, then teleportation might simply equate to suicide.
Another layer of complexity arises when creating a duplicate: we then have two identical identities existing in different locations. What is the future for the copy? How should it navigate life after fulfilling the reason for its teleportation, especially as more copies emerge with each instance? If we decide to eliminate the “extra” duplicates, who should face destruction—the original or the copies? Given their identical nature, isn’t the deletion of a copy also a form of murder, and would the copy consent to its own termination?
I invite you to share your thoughts on this complex issue in the comments below; I look forward to discussing it further!
If you're interested in more articles about space and related topics, please give a clap!
Also, consider subscribing to my channel and asking any questions you may have; I’ll address them in upcoming articles. If you appreciate my work, you can support me by becoming a Medium member for just $5 a month, helping us produce even better content.
Chapter 2: Theoretical Insights on Teleportation
The first video titled "Can we teleport a person to another planet?" delves into the scientific theories and possibilities of human teleportation, examining the underlying physics and its implications for future exploration.
The second video, "Why You Don't Want Teleportation," discusses the potential negative consequences and ethical challenges associated with the concept of teleportation, providing a counterpoint to its allure.