The Inevitable Collapse of Conservative Ideology in America
Written on
The Historical Context of American Conservatism
Since the 1960s, the Republican Party has represented conservative values in the United States, advocating for minimal government intervention, low taxation, fiscal discipline, and socially conservative principles, alongside a free-market approach. Despite their claims, the actual implementation of these policies often diverged significantly from their professed principles.
The evidence accumulated over decades indicates that many of their economic strategies were misguided or poorly executed. The supposed benefits of wealth trickling down never materialized, tax reductions failed to balance out the budget, anti-labor measures led to outsourcing and lower wages, and supply-side economics merely perpetuated wealth inequality. Deregulation did not foster competition or drive down prices; instead, it resulted in soaring profits for the affluent while exacerbating the wealth divide.
The Unfolding Crisis in the UK
Currently, in the UK, Liz Truss has been appointed as the fifth Prime Minister in a span of six years amid significant economic turmoil, including soaring inflation, recession fears, labor strikes, and rising energy costs. Her proposed solutions to these pressing issues involve tax cuts and spending reductions, a strategy likely to enrich the affluent while worsening conditions for the less fortunate.
A common conservative argument posits that spending cannot resolve economic woes. However, historical data supports the notion that substantial stimulus measures effectively avert prolonged economic downturns. The approach of withdrawing and hoping for improvement has historically led to more severe consequences.
In times of economic distress, wealthier individuals tend to benefit from lower taxes, allowing them to acquire resources at reduced costs, further compounding inequality when recovery occurs. This dynamic suggests that a government focused on safeguarding the interests of the wealthy will inevitably perpetuate these disparities.
The Shift Towards Culture War Politics
Historically, the Republican Party prioritized economic conservatism, relegating social issues to a secondary role, which sometimes frustrated social conservatives. This arrangement allowed social conservatives to support economic policies in exchange for judicial appointments favoring their views on issues like abortion and same-sex marriage.
However, under Donald Trump’s leadership, the focus has shifted dramatically towards cultural issues. This change has seen the party increasingly embrace government intervention in free markets, targeting corporations that oppose their social agenda and adopting a more isolationist stance on foreign policy.
The party has effectively abandoned its previous policy platform in favor of cultural conflicts surrounding topics like Critical Race Theory, transgender rights in education, and reproductive rights, among others.
The Discrepancies in Conservative Principles
Mike Johnson, a Republican representative from Louisiana, outlines what he identifies as the seven foundational principles of modern American conservatism: Individual Freedom, Limited Government, The Rule of Law, Peace through Strength, Fiscal Responsibility, Free Markets, and Human Dignity. While these principles are often echoed in Republican rhetoric, their application has become increasingly selective.
- Individual Freedom: The party has shifted towards advocating for freedoms that serve its interests while restricting similar rights for others.
- Limited Government: Republicans emphasize state rights selectively, favoring federal intervention when it aligns with their agenda.
- The Rule of Law: The party's commitment to law and order often reflects a biased enforcement that serves its interests.
- Peace through Strength: Military might is frequently leveraged for personal gain rather than the promotion of true peace.
- Fiscal Responsibility: Claims of concern for fiscal discipline mask efforts to dismantle federal oversight, even as Republican leadership has contributed to significant budget deficits.
- Free Markets: The party champions free-market principles until they face opposition from entities challenging their agenda.
- Human Dignity: The focus on dignity often serves as a veneer for promoting a narrow moral framework that prioritizes certain religious beliefs.
The True Cost of Conservative Policies
Republicans consistently oppose funding programs aimed at alleviating poverty, such as education, healthcare, and housing assistance. However, when the consequences of poverty manifest, they allocate substantial taxpayer resources towards policing and incarceration, often exceeding preventive investments.
The logical inconsistency is striking; rather than addressing the root causes of poverty, the system punishes those who struggle, leading to costly and ineffective solutions. This pattern mirrors the healthcare system, which tends to profit from ongoing treatment rather than actual cures.
As we confront the realities of our socio-political landscape, the analogy of a cold civil war in America holds true. Both parties view themselves as engaged in a struggle for survival, convinced that victory is the only path forward.
Ryan P. Williams, president of the Claremont Institute, noted in 2018 that our current polarization revolves around fundamental questions of human nature and justice. The outcome of this ideological battle will likely shape the political landscape for generations to come.
In the words of Colonel Kilgore from "Apocalypse Now," "Someday this war’s gonna end." The challenges ahead will require a reckoning with the disparities fostered by conservative policies.
The first video, "The Rise of Conservatism: Crash Course US History #41," explores the historical development of conservative ideology in America and its implications.
The second video, "What Does Conservatism Have to Say About the Global Pandemic?" delves into the conservative perspective on contemporary global issues.
If you found this analysis insightful, consider following for more posts by David Todd McCarty. For those not yet subscribed to Medium, now is a great time to explore a wealth of articles from various writers.
